“If the only tool you have is a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail.”
– Abraham Maslow
The single biggest reason for startup failure is “no market need” – I like to call this the “solution looking for a problem” syndrome.
Unfortunately, this scenario is extremely common in startups. It is also common to find it in more established organizations.
Why does it happen? Entrepreneurial solution creators get so excited and passionate about their new product and/or service innovation that they gloss over a fundamental requirement for business success: To be viable your offering must address a real problem in the market that buyers actually want to solve.
The key takeaway for business growth leaders is to avoid falling in love with your offering until you have validated there is a market for it. To build and grow a successful business, you have to make something that people actually want to buy.
Growth leaders that ignore this wisdom will end up spending a lot of time and money trying to sell something that nobody will pay for. This can have fatal ramifications for a career, and an organization.
While the solution is simple, it is not always easy to do.
Start here…
First Identify Potential Problems to Solve
“It isn’t that they cannot find the solution. It is that they cannot see the problem.”
– G.K Chesterton
Begin your solution discovery journey by putting a customer hat on. Think deeply about significant problems that need solving.
This research exercise should be heavily influenced by your personal and professional life experiences. Your background and history can be a powerful lens through which to view the world.
For B2B problems, it is often much easier to focus in on a specific industry vertical or functional area. Ideally, one that you know intimately. For B2C problems, think about a specific demographic or consumer profile to get started.
When you identify a potential problem to solve, a pain to eliminate, or some meaningful metric that your future market would like to improve then you are ready to begin thinking about solutions.
But first, it is absolutely vital that you get feedback on the problem you have identified and confirmation from actual prospects that they care about a potential solution.
Here’s how…
Validate the Problem with Real Live Prospects
“You can increase your problem-solving skills by honing your question-asking ability.”
– Michael J. Gelb
At this stage, armed with a hypothesis of a problem, many startup founders start building their new product and/or service. This is a big mistake. Why? You simply do not know enough yet. Before doing any development work you need to get out of the building and talk to real live prospects in the market.
The smartest way to validate your problem-to-solve is to talk to at least 20 (preferably more) potential customers. You need to validate your hypothesis of the problem that you think they are experiencing.
Your goal is to get a better understanding of how they articulate the problem. What are their pain points? What is their desired outcome? What must the solution include? What is a solution worth to them personally? To their organizations?
These interviews must be done with real potential buyers who are experiencing the problem you want to solve. Even more importantly, these must be prospects who can make a purchase decision. For example interviewing a sales rep about a potential productivity tool might yield a positive response, but they are not your buyer…you need to validate with their sales manager, the one who has a budget and the ability to actually buy a sales productivity tool.
Why should you push for a least 20 interviews? Because you will learn and refine your problem hypothesis as you go.
- The first three interviews (numbers 1-to-3) will help you understand and refine the problem statement. You will learn how to articulate it in the buyer’s language. You will also learn what questions to ask. While you might think you understand it, you are biased to the seller’s point of view, not the buyer’s. These first interviews will give you a much richer understanding of the problem from the buyer’s perspective.
- The next seven interviews (numbers 4-to-10) will confirm the patterns and observations you made in the first round. You learn how to define the problem from the first three interviews and confirm your learnings in the second set of seven.
- The next ten interviews (numbers 11-to-20) will provide you with a much deeper viewpoint on the problem, and help you to narrow in on the most impactful parts. This is where you will begin to nail your pitch, and where you will start to form a strong thesis around the eventual solution. For style points you can interview people from different sizes of organization, or tangential industries to your target, to gain a broader perspective on the problem.
One important caveat with your interviews: make sure these are conducted with actual potential customers. While it might be easier to interview your friends or people you know, they won’t give you the unvarnished truth that you need.
Talk to prospects who you don’t know, and who don’t know you.
And pay attention to what you hear…
Listen Carefully to Identify the Right Problem
“Solving problems means listening.”
– Richard Branson
While this buyer interviewing process is an exceptional learning opportunity, it can also be painful. You might not get positive feedback, or you might receive conflicting signals about the actual problem. Worst case, you get indifference…which means there is not a lot of energy around the problem or a solution.
Indifference is the kiss of death. What you are seeking is loud confirmation, or strong resistance.
Regardless of whether the feedback is positive, negative, or mediocre – the most important thing is to pay attention. Listen to what the potential buyers are telling you. It is much easier to make changes to your assumptions and plans at this early stage than it is later down the road after you have invested a lot of time and money to create a solution for a problem nobody cares about.
Based on your interviews you should now be able to answer some important questions:
- Do people really have the problem you think they have?
- How do they describe it?
- How do they approach the problem today?
- Is your concept a better alternative for them?
- What is solving the problem worth?
“We fail more often because we solve the wrong problem than because we get the wrong solution to the right problem.”
– Russell L. Ackoff
At this point, assuming the feedback was mostly positive and you have validated the problem, you in a great position to begin to think about potential solutions.
Solutioning Mode
“We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them.”
– Albert Einstein
Perhaps the single most important piece of advice for entrepreneurs and growth leaders who want to avoid being a solution looking for a problem is this:
Fall in love with the problem first, not your proposed solution.
This mindset shift is so powerful because solutions may shift and morph over time, but problems are usually more enduring. There are many benefits to starting with a validated problem:
- When you start with a validated problem, you have the flexibility to create multiple solutions.
- When you start with a validated problem, you avoid falling in love with every one of your ideas, even the bad ones!
- When you start with a validated problem, you will naturally gravitate to the solution that best solves the problem, and that buyers will pay you for.
- When you start with a validated problem, you are not constrained by a pre-formed solution, you have the opportunity to truly innovate.
Be the Solution to a Significant Problem
“Giving up is the most painful way of solving a problem.”
-Anonymous
Validating a market problem is not always easy, but it is always worthwhile.
The investment you and your team make in developing a deep understanding of the customer challenge will pay off in spades. Not only will it result in a solution that customers will pay for, but you will also develop a much deeper understanding of how to sell to them, and how to service them once they do become your customer.
Instead of being a solution looking for a problem, search out significant problems, understand them inside and out, and then create a compelling solution to sell.
Pretty simple, right?!
-Onward
About the author: Kimball Norup is the founder of 1CMO Consulting, a business strategy and growth advisory firm based in Sonoma, California. To read prior articles, or sign up to receive future ones by email, click here.