Making the Strategy Decision

“The inability to make decisions is one of the principal reasons executives fail. Deficiency in decision making ability ranks much higher than lack of specific knowledge or technical know-how as an indicator of leadership failure.” – John C. Maxwell

Leaders and their teams must make strategic decisions throughout the VUCA Strategic Planning process. Aside from the ultimate “go/no-go” execution decision, perhaps no decision is more important that the one made after a strategy has been formulated: Is it the right strategy to help the organization achieve its long-term goals, and should a strategic plan be created in order to execute the chosen strategy?

Decision-Making Defined

In psychology, decision-making is defined as a cognitive process, which results in the selection of a belief or a course of action among several possible alternative options. In a business context, decision-making is the process of identifying and evaluating alternatives to pick one best option based on the knowledge, experience, values, preferences and beliefs of the decision-maker. 

Research suggests that each of us make thousands of decisions every day, many of them sub-consciously. These decisions range from the mundane, which generally do not require much thought (for example, “White shirt or blue shirt?” or, “Do I want another cup of coffee?”) to the more complex (ex. “Should I look for a new job?” or, “Where do I want to live?”) which can be significantly more difficult to decide.

It is the same with organizations. Leaders and their teams are making decisions every day and at every level. Decision-making within the organization can range from routine operational decisions, to more complex managerial decisions, all the way up to challenging strategic decisions, which can shape the future trajectory of the organization.

The Peril of Making Strategic Decisions

The most important and difficult decisions – the strategic decisions with significant consequences for the performance of the team or the future success and viability of the organization – carry the most risk for leaders. Strategic decisions call for a thoughtful approach.

Strategic decisions are risky, and never easy. They often cause leaders the most angst because they are decisions that are both high in potential impact, but also high in terms of investment of scarce company resources. Furthermore, strategic decisions are not transactional (like a consumer selecting a box of cereal at the grocery store) but instead are complex and dynamic situations where the leader can influence the outcome by how they lead and manage the team. Adding even more complexity, their organization is likely competing with others – where picking the right strategy and doing better than rivals could mean the difference between winning and losing, between growth and bankruptcy. Adding in the additional uncertainty of a VUCA (volatile, uncertain, complex, ambiguous) environment just intensifies the risk.

This means strategic decision-makers need two vital, yet often contradictory skills: clear analysis, and the ability to take swift and bold action in the face of uncertainty.

Great Leaders are Decisive

Great leaders are decisive – they understand how to balance emotion with logic, and then effectively make decisions that positively impact their organizations and all their constituents.

Making good strategic decisions in challenging situations is always difficult because these types of decisions involve change, uncertainty, anxiety, stress, and sometimes the unfavorable or less than enthusiastic reactions of others.

Great leaders also have great situational awareness – they instinctively know when to move quickly and proceed with decision-making using whatever information is available, versus when they need to take more time and gather additional information.

Avoiding Paralysis by Analysis

Uncertainty creates an uncomfortable decision-making platform for leaders, and can lead to a phenomenon called analysis paralysis.

This is a common dynamic where decision-makers try to eliminate the uncertainty they are facing by over-analyzing the situation. Often to no avail.

The challenge with delaying a decision in order to gather more information is knowing when to stop. Many leaders mistakenly believe you cannot have too much information, but data gathering takes time and having too much data to consider can be paralyzing, and a distraction from taking a big picture view or focusing on the most important data points.

The reality is most decisions, especially the strategic ones, are made with less than perfect information. The pressure of trying to craft strategy that overcomes the uncertainty caused by a VUCA environment just ends up wasting valuable time and energy – scarce resources better spent on planning and execution.

Getting to Done

Effective strategic decision-making has another vital element: It is not just about selecting the alternative that best satisfies the business objective, it is also about making sure it is something that is implemented and actually gets done.

An unfortunate by-product of focusing too hard (and too long!) on selecting the ideal option is neglecting the opportunity cost of not taking action sooner.

Scott McNealy, co-founder of Sun Microsystems and its CEO for 22 years, was asked how he made difficult decisions and responded by saying, “It’s important to make good decisions. But I spend much less time and energy worrying about ‘making the right decision’ and much more time and energy ensuring that any decision I make turns out right.”

Merely deciding on the “best” option does not guarantee a successful outcome, just as making a poor choice does not necessarily doom the initiative to failure. It is what happens next, which determines your success.

As the immortal management theorist, Peter Drucker said, “Unless a decision has ‘degenerated into work’, it is not a decision. It is at best a good intention.”

This is the connection of decision-making into the VUCA Strategic Planning framework.

Where Does Decision Making Fit into VUCA Strategic Planning?

As a quick refresher, the Core Ideology of the organization is the planning filter that any strategy will be evaluated against, and the Envisioned Future is the definition for the desired future state. When combined with robust Situational Awareness, detailing the current state of the organization and its operating environment, your Core Ideology and Envisioned Future create the springboard for strategy development. Previous articles have described these three planning elements in detail:

• Core Ideology – defining the mission, values, and purpose of the organization. These elements describe why the organization exists and what it stands for. They form the “true North” guideposts for making strategic decisions and are the foundation for any VUCA plan.
• Envisioned Future – defining a clear vision of what the organization aspires to become or achieve and your long-term goals. These elements explain the desired “future state” of the organization, and the long-term goals you and your team are working towards achieving in order to get there.
• Situational Awareness – a thorough analysis of the environment in which the organization operates. Situational awareness involves knowing where you are (“current state”) and being aware of what is happening in your environment (internal and external perspective), in order to better understand how information, events, and one’s own actions will impact both immediate and future outcomes.

With this solid planning foundation, leaders are ready to consider strategic options that will enable the organization to bridge the gap between the current state and the desired future state while factoring in the operating environment as revealed by the Situational analysis. This is where strategy comes into play:

• Strategy – defining the approach that will guide individuals and teams on “how” to achieve the short-term objectives that move the organization from its starting point towards achieving its long-term goals. Strategy plays a vital role in VUCA strategic planning. It is quite literally the vehicle that will help the organization bridge the “gap” between where it is today (its current state) and where it wants to be in the future (desired future state).

Formulating strategy is not easy. Unfortunately, for leaders it only signals the beginning of the next phase of the VUCA Strategic Planning process – making a strategy decision:

• Strategy Decision – once a strategy has been formulated, leaders face a significant decision: Is it the right strategy to help the organization achieve its long-term goals? If the decision is to move ahead with executing a chosen strategy then it is time to commit, and proceed with creating a complete Strategic Plan designed to ensure the successful execution of it.

Basic 5-step Decision Making Process

Making the strategy selection decision can be simplified by following a proven 5-step process:

1. Identify the decision: The first step in making the best decision for the organization is to recognize the problem or opportunity, and decide to address it. At this stage in the VUCA Strategic Planning process, that should be straightforward to answer! Clearly, the objective is to pick a strategy.
2. Gather information: Next, you want to gather the information you need in order to make a decision based on facts and data. If you’ve been following the VUCA Strategic Planning framework so far, this should also be in your hands at this point. You and your team will have gained solid Situational Awareness of the salient factors present in your operating environment. The Core Ideology and Envisioned Future of the organization should provide the context you need to make a decision.
3. Identify alternatives: As part of the strategy formulation process, your team likely identified several potentially viable alternative strategies with one emerging as the preferred approach. By identifying these potential alternatives, you are ready for the next step.
4. Weigh the evidence:In this step, you need to evaluate the feasibility, acceptability, and desirability of each alternative option. There are many sophisticated techniques to do this, but the simplest is just to consider the pros and cons of each option. Which leads us to the final step.
5. Choose among alternatives:In this final step, you want to choose the strategy option that has the highest probability of success. When it is time to make your decision, be sure that you understand the risks involved with your chosen strategy. Sometimes a new strategy will emerge at this stage, formed by combining elements of alternative strategies.

Criteria for Evaluating Your Strategy Decision

Once you have selected your strategy, it is a good idea to do a quick evaluation before proceeding. Here are some key elements to consider:

1. Core Ideology: The chosen strategy does not contradict the Mission and Values of the organization, and supports or enables your Purpose.
2. Situational Awareness: You have clarity on the starting position (current state), and have considered all of the environmental (internal and external) factors that could influence the successful execution of the chosen strategy.
3. Envisioned Future: You (and your team) still believe in the long-term goal (future state) for the organization, and that it can be achieved, or enabled by, the successful execution of the strategy.
4. Diagnosis: The diagnosis of the challenge is reasonable, and you can defend it. This is the logical and fact-based explanation for the reason(s) behind the challenge that the organization is facing.
5. Hypothesis: A clear and simple hypothesis on the solution to the challenge, one that the strategy could reasonably be expected to solve.
6. Bias: A cognitive bias is a type of error in thinking that can affect our decision-making and judgement. There are many to consider, but you obviously want to avoid them when choosing your preferred strategy.

These elements provide helpful criteria for leaders to use when evaluating any considered strategy.

If, and only if, these conditions are satisfied, then you are in a good position to make the final decision and proceed with developing a VUCA Plan.

Next Steps

Once a leader has made the strategic decision on strategy, it is time to make the decision tangible by developing a plan that details the execution of the strategy leading to the achievement of your defined objective(s).

Upcoming articles will cover the details of creating a VUCA Strategic Plan, the importance of scenario analysis in strategic planning, and the value of taking a portfolio approach to managing your strategic initiatives.

-Onward